Home
/
Fiction
/
The Scatter Here is Too Great
The Scatter Here is Too Great
Jul 21, 2025 1:55 AM

Author:Bilal Tanweer

The Scatter Here is Too Great

Shortlisted for the 2015 DSC Prize for South Asian Literature

Winner of the Shakti Bhatt First Book Prize 2014

The Scatter Here Is Too Great heralds a major new voice from Pakistan with a stunning debut - a novel told in a rich variety of distinctive voices that converge at a single horrific event: a bomb blast at a station in the heart of the city.

Comrade Sukhansaz, an old communist poet, is harassed on a bus full of college students minutes before the blast. His son, a wealthy middle-aged businessman, yearns for his own estranged child. A young man, Sadeq, has a dead-end job snatching cars from people who have defaulted on their bank loans, while his girlfriend spins tales for her young brother to conceal her own heartbreak. An ambulance driver picking up the bodies after the blast has a shocking encounter with two strange-looking men whom nobody else seems to notice. And in the midst of it all, a solitary writer, tormented with grief for his dead father, struggles to find words.

In a style that is at once inventive and deeply moving, Tanweer reveals the pain, loneliness and longing of these characters and celebrates the power of the written word to heal individuals and communities plagued by violence. Elegantly weaving together a striking portrait of a city and its people, The Scatter Here Is Too great is a love story written to Karachi - as vibrant and varied in its characters, passions, and idiosyncrasies as the city itself.

Reviews

A beautiful debut. A blood-soaked love letter to Karachi.

—— Mohammed Hanif

Timely and unconventional… Its beautiful fragments coalesce to form an elaborate, haunting portrait of urban Pakistan, one that is rich with acute sociological detail and subtle existential contemplation.

—— Hirsh Sawhney , Guardian

A superb and genuinely exciting debut. By the end of this book Tanweer had made me see that certain things are more beautiful and valuable for having been broken.

—— Nadeem Aslam

Bilal Tanweer uses his many gifts as a writer to evoke a Karachi of humour, violence, frustration, love - and breathtaking stories at every turn. A wonderful debut.

—— Kamila Shamsie

Bilal Tanweer has written a modern love letter - furious, passionate, playful, and longing - to Pakistan. And in his brilliant hands he tells the universal story of home.

—— Ben Marcus

An impressive, poignant read.

—— Jennifer Lipman , Running in Heels

Intriguing… Each of the voices rings emotionally true.

—— Jon Wise , Weekend Sport

it’s beautiful fragments coalesce to form an elaborate, haunting portrait of urban Pakistan, rich with acute sociological detail and subtle existential contemplation

—— Hirsh Sawhney , Guardian

A Concise Chinese-English Dictionary for Lovers is an intriguing, funny and unusual novel about what gets lost in translation

—— Herald

An uplifting novel with moments of great poignancy and pathos

—— Tatler

Written with compelling simplicity.

—— Kerry Fowler , Sainsbury's Magazine

Cleverly constructed, carefully written and deservedly longlisted for this year’s Booker Prize.

—— Harry Ritchie , Daily Mail

Clegg's story is frequently affecting.

—— James Kidd , Independent

At times a harrowing read, the slow and deliberate manner with which connections are revealed and questions answered is genuinely satisfying. By the time Clegg’s narrative strands converge, the glimpse that he grants of a brighter future feels earned.

—— Stephanie Cross , Lady

An emotionally resonant debut.

—— Sunday Times

A moving lament on guilt and grief, not to mention a gripping thriller.

—— Harpers Bazaar

A sad yet hopeful novel built from both suffering and kindness.

—— Erica Wagner , New Statesman

Poignant and haunting debut.

—— Suzi Farry , Sunday Express

Clegg shows an impressive depth and range of voice as he tells a story of friendships, broken families, burgeoning love, and the aftermath of grief.

—— Mail on Sunday

Deeply moving.

—— Psychologies

Clegg is committed to unravelling the complexities of human nature.

—— Janette Currie , Independent on Sunday

Through distinctive and instantly recognisable characters, this novel finds beauty in pain, grief and regret.

—— UK Press Syndication

A true beauty of a novel.

—— Georgina Lane , Belle About Town

Clegg writes with warmth and a deep understanding of grief.

—— Saga Magazine

Wonderful narrative of chance, grief, and the ways we feed on and nourish each other.

—— John Burnside , New Statesman

Fabulous.

—— James Kidd , Independent

Told its heart-breaking tale with tenderness and verve.

—— Alex Preston , Observer

A work full of secrets, shame and scandal.

—— Fiona Wilson , The Times

A story of what can be found when so much has been snatched away.

—— Kerry Fowler , Sainsbury’s Magazine

A meditation on enduring the unendurable… This is a wonderful and deeply moving novel.

—— Clare Clark , Guardian

A beautiful, heart-rending novel of quiet, understated tragedy… Sensitive and insightful, heart-breaking and hopeful… [A] tender, wise and hopeful novel.

—— Hannah Beckerman , Observer
Comments
Welcome to zzdbook comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.zzdbook.com All Rights Reserved